I found two especially interesting reviews, both asking questions/making claims about realism in the novel:
Review of
Miss Malevolent (a novel with a key):
http://ezproxy.library.nyu.edu:10446/myArchive/restoreArticleItem.do?method=restore&BackTo=myArchive&BackToParam=folder=articles&QueryType=articles&id=18609&journalID=e936
"In the word 'portrait' lies the explanation, for a portrait, if it be worth anything, is the visual image of an individual which has passed through a mind, gaining significance in the process. and in looking at a great portrait we are thinking not so much of the individual sitter as the significance that individual has gained in his passage through the artist's mind...the author of
Miss Malevolent has given us not portraits, but exceedingly cheap photographs of the members of a small artistic and literary set with which he appears to have some acquaintance...If these were portraits painted with the insight and feeling by an artist, if they had any significance beyond the most petty externals of their originals, they might be tolerable...not for a moment does he author get beneath the surface."
"An Inquiry from South Africa"
http://ezproxy.library.nyu.edu:10446/myArchive/restoreArticleItem.do?method=restore&BackTo=myArchive&BackToParam=folder=articles&QueryType=articles&id=18608&journalID=e936
Sir--I have lately been reading Lord Beaconsfield's novels, and write to ask you whether you could either supply me with a key to the various characters, or else tell me where I may find one? It would, no doubt, be an easy task for anyone well posted in the political history of the earlier part of this century to identify not only every important character, but also all the important events which figure in these stories; and such a list would add immensely to the interest of ordinary readers like myself, who find themselves ill-supplied in this respect...In this connexion I have been wondering what may be the technical definition of (1) the historical novel proper, and (2) the modern
roman a clef, and what the actual line of demarcation between them? In which class are we to place Lord Beaconsfield's brilliant works? The subject has raised some interesting questions in my mind, which I should be glad to see treated at length by a competent hand...Again, am I right in assuming that the true
roman a clef must present one or more portraits drawn not merely from 'the life,' but from the life of some distinguished public character?"
I'd be interested to look at more reviews of novels with a key, and see how reviewers' understandings of novels with a key developed over the course of the 19th century.