-It seems there’s some debate over the precise definition of a novel with a key: while books with published companion glosses are fairly rare, the genre of roman a clef appears to more generally encompass novels with characters deliberately based on real figures. That said, it is not entirely clear what differentiates a roman a clef from simple literary non-fiction—some of the information I found on this didn’t seem to distinguish between the two. It seems the primary difference is that novels with keys generally involve an extraliterary agenda of some sort.
-The construction of the appearance of the real obviously occupies a different role in novels that purport to be based on reality—in such works, the minutiae are never Barthesian objects intended only to invoke the appearance of reality—rather, they are all loaded clues (or have the potential to appear as such, regardless of their basis in truth). Thus readers attempting to identify the personages represented within the book would likely have scrutinized seemingly innocuous details, searching for revelations.
-A novel with a key involves certain narrative constraints, as an author who purports to have witnessed real events is limited by the boundaries of human knowledge and thus cannot claim omniscience. This method, however, might have been used to assert authorial control—an author possessing an exclusive insider’s perspective might actually appear to have more control over the literary domain than an author of pure fiction. As we have seen, many theorists denigrate the fiction-writer’s post-compositional authority, but writers who portray ostensibly real events are not as vulnerable to this sort of criticism.
-Difficulties reconciling fact and fiction have historically resulted in scandal: passages from The Portrait of Dorian Gray were employed as evidence against Wilde during his sodomy trial, with prosecutors insisting that the homoeroticism in the story was reflected in Wilde’s relationships with friends, on whom some of the characters were supposedly based. Similarly, modern readers clearly have different standards for evaluating fact and fiction, even when both are presented as entertainment—examples might include the James Frey/Misha Defonseca memoir-fabrication scandals, though those books purported to be straight non-fiction rather than novels with keys. Similarly, fans of Uncle Tom’s Cabin fiercely maintained the novel’s basis in truth, as though basis in fact validated its philosophical content: “[Stowe sought] a grand purpose, to attack and subvert A SYSTEM: the only condition, in this view, being, that it is founded, not upon exaggeration and misrepresentation, but upon TRUTH.... [A Key to Uncle Tom's Cabin] is, in fact, simply a series of Proofs and Illustrations of the truth of her representations. We have examined this Key to the Cabin with some attention, and are of opinion that its alleged facts are such as must be answered; or those whose accusations provoked its publication, will have succeeded in only placing a professed Fiction upon the solid basis of Fact” (Samuel Warren, review of Uncle Tom’s Cabin). (Eccentric text effects original).
-The best contemporary examples I could find information on are The Devil Wears Prada and Primary Colors—of Primary Colors, one reviewer complained that he “found Joe Klein's political roman a clef, Primary Colors, to be mostly a clef and quite insubstantial as roman. Once you got through the first fifty pages and aligned each fictional personage with his or her real-life counterpart (that one's Stephanopoulos! there's Carville!), scant novelistic pleasure was left in the way of characterizations, atmosphere, or political insight (as opposed to political knowingness, which the book had in abundance)” (Richard Alleva, Commonweal). Based on this, it would seem that in affirming the authorial voice this genre perhaps impairs the generation of any sort of actual discourse.