Thursday, April 21, 2011

Week XIV, Paratext Research Exercise: “The Lifted Veil”

“The Lifted Veil” originally appeared in Blackwood’s surrounded by very little particular paratext save the title (the magazine itself does include some paratext). This lack of paratext is itself revealing, as the article and index omit the author’s name (per Blackwood’s policy). The lack of authorial attribution seems somewhat fitting given the topic of the story—while it seems unlikely that any educated reader would actually believe the story to be true, the lack of attribution makes it seem a bit more organic and thus heightens the spookiness. I suppose this is somewhat analogous to modern horror movies that purport to be based on a true story.

The story was published without attribution contrary to George Eliot’s request—while she believed that attribution would mitigate the false rumors regarding the identity of the author of Adam Bede, Blackwood was reluctant to associate the name with a story both ghastly and stylistically anomalous. Blackwood generally appears ambivalent towards the story, often citing its cheerlessness and its stylistic distance from the rest of Eliot’s corpus. George Eliot and George Henry Lewes campaigned both for her name to appear in the original printing and for the story to be included in a later Eliot collection—in both instances, however, Blackwood’s opinions prevailed. It is unclear as to whether Eliot actually capitulated to him despite her own judgment, or if she ultimately deferred to his (presumably) greater knowledge of marketing.

“The Lifted Veil” was eventually released in a collection with “Brother Jacob”, another grim and ostensibly disparate story. Unlike the original article, the collection emphasizes Eliot’s authorship—her name appears several times in the opening paratext, and the volume is clearly advertised as an Eliot collection rather than as a generic short story collection. Furthermore, her other works are cited on one of the book’s title pages—this emphasizes Eliot’s fame and artistic respectability, but also explicitly associates her distinguished corpus with these previously unacknowledged tales. Perhaps by this time Eliot was established enough that such aberrant works could not dislodge either her reputation or her defined style? Or perhaps her name would guarantee increased sales, regardless of content?

In the later version, there remains little story-specific paratext. Unlike the magazine version, this version is presented in standard “novel” form—that is, the pages are not double-columned as in the earlier version. Since the original story shared formatting similarities with factual articles/news stories, its fictitiousness was perhaps less explicit. Here, the emphasis on authorship and the novel-type formatting forces the reader to acknowledge the story’s status as a creation.

Eliot appears to have had an unusual relationship with this story—while she minimizes its importance in her letters to Blackwood, the account (assuming its accuracy) related by her acquaintance indicates that Eliot was sensitive towards any suggestion of criticism towards “The Lifted Veil”, perhaps because the criticism seems rooted in presumptuous contentions regarding her “quintessential” style—of course, it is somewhat tautological to define an author’s style by disregarding ostensibly non-representative portions of her corpus, and this inherent problem also relates to the Eliot anthologizing issues that Leah Price cites.

Friday, March 25, 2011

Thoughts on Archive Research

My research interests involved Reade’s merging of fact and fiction, his research methodology, and the factual bases for many of the events portrayed in the novel. Topics of particular interest: whether Reade based his novels on individual accounts of injustice or if he derived a single story by aggregating/fusing various accounts; whether institutional reform was a burgeoning issue at the time of the novel’s composition (for instance, would extensive newspaper debates/accounts of this issue have prompted his initial concern) or whether Reade wanted to bring attention to an unpublicized issue; to what degree were the injustices dramatized, and to what degree were they derived from actual reports; the ways in which Reade deviates/explicitly fictionalizes real events; Reade’s research process/methodology (did it involve active research, such as site-visits or interviews, or just source research?); the factual basis for the “railroad bubble” and problems involve financial corruption/lack of deposit insurance.

I had minor success in examining a few of these questions, but time constraints and simple lack of adequate information prohibited me from exploring others. I mostly explored his notebook and his notecards; the notebook contained sparse personal commentary and was dominated by newspaper clippings. Reade’s own organizational quirks occasionally impaired interpretation of the notecards. Furthermore, as Ester points out, some of the writing was in French/Latin/indecipherable script.

I found his notebook to be the most edifying. Judging from its organization—if we assume he used the pages in order—Reade appears to have composed the novel in segments. The notebook begins with a character sketch of Julia that includes various portions of her dialogue throughout the novel. Later sections of the notebook relate to various chronologically disparate sections of the book—so it seems that he was conducting research continuously, as he wrote/formulated the characters and the plot.
Given the “resource lists” that he includes, it appears that he likely fused information from a variety of sources on the same topic. I was surprised by the specificity of some of his topics of research. For instance, on a page titled “Medicina”, he has a clipping from an article discussing the critical importance of sleep to one’s health:


“One of the very worst economies of time is that filched from necessary sleep…it is a ruinous mistake…We caution parents particularly not to allow their children to be waked up of mornings; let nature wake them up…Being waked up earlier…has given many a beautiful and promising child brain fever. “

Under this clipping is a handwritten note:
“D Makes Lucy cry for waking her child.”

After reading this passage I vaguely recalled a throwaway reference to the importance of sleep within the novel, I think in relation to Julia. Similarly, the notebook contains an article regarding a house fire that resulted in two deaths; while completely unrelated to the plot of the novel, the article does briefly discuss the fire brigade, so presumably this relates to Edward’s eventual profession.

Given the abundance of articles on deplorable conditions in lunatic asylums, it seems that that this issue was in fact highly publicized prior to Reade’s composition of the novel. Thus, the book probably represents a contribution to an existing debate rather than an actual spark for debate. Also, a number of his articles came from Harper’s, which seems odd as this is a U.S. publication and he addresses (albeit similar) issues involving British social policy. I found that at least one of these articles mirrored a passage from the novel extremely closely, indicating that—at least at times—Reade imported material with little or no modification.


Ultimately, I think I managed to gather a great deal of information that is interesting but not extensive enough to develop any cohesive research conclusions. I think our unavoidable time constraints made it difficult to achieve any depth on a single subject—at least, I felt as though I spent much of the time gathering fairly preliminary information (though this might also be because my research interests were quite broad—in retrospect, I think I probably should have narrowed them down). That said, it was certainly an enjoyable experience and I think that I now have a better sense of how to approach such materials more efficiently in the future.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Charles Reade Research

Although I was hoping to find the answer to my research question in the two hours we spent at the archive, I knew that would not be possible. I wasn't expecting my question to change but as I continued to peruse through Reade's notes, I found my research question morphing. Rather than trying to research Reade's opinions on race, I decided that it would be more useful and easier to research the conditions and views of race as seen in the text. I had thought that Reade's opinion on race would be fairly easy to discern especially since he had a notebook dedicated to race but I found the notebooks to be more about the conditions and general opinions of society as a whole because he was writing primarily for a novel and using information he got from newspapers. This would not tell me anything about his opinion but about society's. The source that I spent the most time with was notebook 94. The barrier that I came up against was that I had not read the book that the notebook was dedicated to. I was able to figure out that it was about slavery in the United States but because of my unfamiliarity I found myself wondering whether some notes were about his characters or about real people he read in the newspapers.

Another barrier I came up against during research was his handwriting and his use of french and latin. What was really curious to me and I wished I had more time to continue thinking about this were Reade's inclusion of certain musings. For example under the heading of College, Reade wrote a question: "Negro blood. not admitted to them. Why?" It's really interesting to me why Reade was wondering about this. It may be from his novel or his own personal musings but I am really not sure. He also had a page listing "distinguished negros", although he had only listed Fredrick Douglass. I really think that reading his novel would have prepared me better for this particular notebook.

One other thing I would like to mention is the experience of handling archival materials. It was a pretty amazing feeling. I especially liked the note cards and the extensive research he did for his novels. Thinking about the history of the pieces and how Charles Reade had owned these materials gives me goosebumps, even today. It may sound corny, but i really felt like I was holding history in my hands. While online transcripts might be more convenient, I still believe that doing the archival research is more important because, at least for me, I felt a true passionate connection in the encounter.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Late Post

I can honestly say that this was the worst week of my Swarthmore Career. Imagine those weeks where everything that can go wrong does go wrong and you get my drift. So aside from complaining about my week the reason for my post is that I realized that I didn't do the Charles Reade research thing so I finally managed to do it today. I think I found the pdf file of the Charles Reade manuscripts. Here's the link:

http://infoshare1.princeton.edu/rbsc2/parrish/21-Reade.pdf

I also found some correspondence from Charles Reade at Yale University. The manuscripts aren't all about Charles Reade but the archive contains some of his letters. Here's an excerpt from the website:

This collection of papers relating to the popular early-Victorian novelist Frederick, known as “Captain” Marryat and his daughter Florence comprises an album in which are pasted letters from Marryat and to him, including letters from William and Thomas Longman, Richard Bentley, William Harrison Ainsworth. The items relating to Florence Marryat include two autograph letters, signed, from Charles Dickens (6 August 1867 and 29 March 1869), and letters from Hamilton Aïdé, George Bentley, Randolph Caldecott, Wilkie Collins, Blanchard Jerrold, Harry Furniss, John Murray, Ouida, Charles Reade, Charlotte Riddell, George Augustus Sala, John Tenniel, and Edmund Yates. Additional material documents Florence Marryat's work for the theater and her career as a literary recitalist and includes notebooks, source material, original artwork, photographs, and ephemera. Also in the collection are letters to Richard Bentley from Edward Bulwer Lytton, Anthony Trollope, and Frances Trollope.

http://www.library.yale.edu/beinecke/brblinfo/brblguide_2001.html

Friday, March 4, 2011

really funny blog post about villette

http://thehairpin.com/2011/01/books-that-beat-their-iconic-sister-books-jane-eyre-vs-villette/

Novel with a Key

I found two especially interesting reviews, both asking questions/making claims about realism in the novel:

Review of Miss Malevolent (a novel with a key):

http://ezproxy.library.nyu.edu:10446/myArchive/restoreArticleItem.do?method=restore&BackTo=myArchive&BackToParam=folder=articles&QueryType=articles&id=18609&journalID=e936

"In the word 'portrait' lies the explanation, for a portrait, if it be worth anything, is the visual image of an individual which has passed through a mind, gaining significance in the process. and in looking at a great portrait we are thinking not so much of the individual sitter as the significance that individual has gained in his passage through the artist's mind...the author of Miss Malevolent has given us not portraits, but exceedingly cheap photographs of the members of a small artistic and literary set with which he appears to have some acquaintance...If these were portraits painted with the insight and feeling by an artist, if they had any significance beyond the most petty externals of their originals, they might be tolerable...not for a moment does he author get beneath the surface."

"An Inquiry from South Africa"

http://ezproxy.library.nyu.edu:10446/myArchive/restoreArticleItem.do?method=restore&BackTo=myArchive&BackToParam=folder=articles&QueryType=articles&id=18608&journalID=e936

Sir--I have lately been reading Lord Beaconsfield's novels, and write to ask you whether you could either supply me with a key to the various characters, or else tell me where I may find one? It would, no doubt, be an easy task for anyone well posted in the political history of the earlier part of this century to identify not only every important character, but also all the important events which figure in these stories; and such a list would add immensely to the interest of ordinary readers like myself, who find themselves ill-supplied in this respect...In this connexion I have been wondering what may be the technical definition of (1) the historical novel proper, and (2) the modern roman a clef, and what the actual line of demarcation between them? In which class are we to place Lord Beaconsfield's brilliant works? The subject has raised some interesting questions in my mind, which I should be glad to see treated at length by a competent hand...Again, am I right in assuming that the true roman a clef must present one or more portraits drawn not merely from 'the life,' but from the life of some distinguished public character?"

I'd be interested to look at more reviews of novels with a key, and see how reviewers' understandings of novels with a key developed over the course of the 19th century.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Novels with a key

This was a frustrating experience in that the contemporary sources I found did not go into much depth in their discussion of the search terms I used - frequently a reviewer would simply observe that the novel at hand was a 'roman a clef', and make little effort to describe the particulars of the genre further. However, there was plenty of contemporary criticism available, much of it dealing with the unnamed real individuals that make a roman a clef or thinly veiled satire the statement that it is. For example, the following article considers an attack on Henry James made by Vernon Lee (a woman); in her novella "Lady Tal", which documents the exploits of a 'fictional' American novelist who is "a kind of Henry James" ("Lady Tal" 194).

http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/henry_james_review/v031/31.3.murphy.html

If I only had the time for further investigation, and the knowledge of the most effective keywords, it would be interesting if and when periodicals were willing to break out the key to the novel - if not a full character list, then are there not times when a reviewer makes a solid inference that a character stands for a real life person? For my account, I did not find such forward accusations.